Friday, 14 March 2014

Predatory Journals

The issue of predatory journals on the ERA list was raised with me recently.  I haven't had time to check how many are on the list but it sounds entirely plausible that there is overlap between Beall's list (http://scholarlyoa.com/publishers/) and the ERA list.

Does it matter?  I'm not sure although it could be a juicy tabloid story if spun the right way.

"PYNE'S SUPER EXPENSIVE AUS  RESEARCH ASSESSMENT EXERCISE WANK RELIES ON DISCREDITED DODGY FRAUDULENT JOURNALS"

(I did enjoy adding Pyne to my headline :>) )

Impact in the citation disciplines is negligible unless the  journals are indexed by the citation supplier - and if they are, they really predatory.  Might be more of a problem in the peer-review disciplines.  Hopefully not too many get nominated for peer review.

Could the ARC to a bulk remove of the Beall's list journals or maybe flag them for the 'peak bodies' to pay special attention to phase 2 of the consultation.

btw if anyone knows of a Beall's list version with ISSN's that could help us all out.

1 comment:

  1. As a follow-up to this I've tried to check the first 100 journals on Beall's stand alone list (http://scholarlyoa.com/individual-journals/). Only found 4 on the ERA draft list. This might not be a representative sample and in some cases, I couldn't find an ISSN or the web page was broken etc. But only 4 is not too bad, I think.

    I can say categorically that Beall's list is not a useful resource to locate instances of good web page design.

    ReplyDelete